Asking for feedback before the guest writes the review

A guest who had a problem will tell you privately if you ask first. If you do not ask, they tell the internet, and the internet does not forget.

The BittaFlow team

3 min read

On this page
  1. Ask privately first, publicly second
  2. The three questions
  3. Timing
  4. The reply that recovers a stay
  5. When to ask for the review
  6. The negative review that arrives anyway
  7. Route the feedback to someone
  8. Look for the pattern, not the score
  9. What not to do
  10. Where BittaFlow fits

The guest checks out at 10:40 and says everything was lovely. At 8pm they leave a three-star review about the noise from the street and the cold breakfast.

The complaint was real. The chance to fix it was at 10:40, and nobody asked.

Ask privately first, publicly second

Two separate asks, in this order:

  1. Feedback, sent the day of departure. Private, short, and genuinely interested.
  2. A review, sent two days later, only to guests who said the stay was good.

Sending both at once means the unhappy guest ignores the feedback form and writes a review instead.

The three questions

Keep it to three, sent as a message rather than a survey link:

  • What worked well?
  • What would you change?
  • Would you stay again?

The third question is the honest one. A guest who says “probably not” is telling you something a five-star form never will.

Timing

Same day, early evening. The guest is home or on a train, the stay is still fresh, and they are not yet back in the routine.

A week later, the memory has become “it was fine” or “it was expensive”, neither of which is useful.

The reply that recovers a stay

If the feedback contains a problem, reply within a day, from a person, with something concrete.

“Thank you for telling us about the noise. The room you had faces the street, and we should have offered you a rear room when you mentioned early breakfast. We’ve noted it on your profile for next time, and we’d like to offer you an upgrade if you come back.”

Three elements: acknowledge the specific thing, say what the hotel should have done, and offer something real. No voucher code, no “we value your feedback”.

When to ask for the review

Only after a positive reply, or a positive feedback form. Two days after departure.

The message should be one line and one link:

“Really glad you enjoyed the stay. If you have a minute, a review here helps other guests find us: [link]”

No incentive. Offering something for a review breaks most platforms’ rules and makes the page worthless.

The negative review that arrives anyway

Reply once, publicly, in plain words. Acknowledge the specific issue, say what changed, and give a contact.

Do not argue about facts in public, even when the guest is wrong. The reply is read by the next hundred people, and they are judging tone, not accuracy.

Route the feedback to someone

Feedback that lands in a shared inbox is read and forgotten. Assign it:

  • Housekeeping issues → housekeeping supervisor, same week.
  • Noise or room allocation → front office.
  • Breakfast and restaurant → food and beverage.
  • Maintenance → logged as a job, with the room number.

One person owns the list and reviews it weekly. Otherwise the same complaint arrives four times before anyone acts.

Look for the pattern, not the score

A single “room was cold” is weather. Six in a month is a radiator or a window.

Count the themes monthly: noise, temperature, breakfast, check-in wait, cleanliness. The top theme is the next thing to fix, regardless of the average rating.

What not to do

  • Send a survey with fifteen questions.
  • Ask for a review from every guest, including the unhappy ones.
  • Reply to feedback with a template that repeats their words back.
  • Offer a discount to remove a review.

Where BittaFlow fits

BittaFlow sends the three-question message on departure day, routes each reply to the right department, and sends the review request only after a positive response. The themes are counted, so the pattern is visible without a spreadsheet.

Ask privately the same day. Then, if the stay was good, ask publicly.

Useful? Send it to someone who runs the phones.